SI Golf Debates Ryder Cup Payments, Rory McIlroy’s Major Hopes, LIV Golf’s Strategy, and Nelly Korda’s Legacy
The SI Golf team returns for Fact or Fiction, diving into the year’s most intriguing storylines. From Ryder Cup payments to LIV Golf’s scheduling and Nelly Korda’s legacy, here’s what our experts think:
Will Ryder Cup Payments Add Pressure to the U.S. Team in 2025?
The U.S. players will reportedly receive $400,000 each at Bethpage, while Europe’s team remains unpaid. Could this financial discrepancy pile more pressure on the Americans?
- Bob Harig: FACT
Payments add scrutiny. While I support compensating players, this disparity invites criticism. Rory McIlroy has dismissed the need for such payments, which only fuels debate and adds unnecessary weight to the U.S. side. - Jeff Ritter: FACT
It’s a PR nightmare. The Americans receiving pay while the Europeans don’t is a divisive issue. Expect it to be a rallying cry for Europe and a persistent distraction for the U.S. - John Schwarb: FACT
If the U.S. falls behind on Day 1, expect heckling and media firestorms. The narrative could overshadow the event, amplifying the stakes for the home team.
Will Rory McIlroy End His Major Drought in 2025?
After winning the DP World Tour Championship and the Race to Dubai, is Rory primed to capture a major in 2025?
- Bob Harig: FACT
With Augusta, Quail Hollow, and Royal Portrush on the calendar, Rory has a real shot. His talent and determination suggest it’s only a matter of time. - Jeff Ritter: FICTION
Rory is always a contender, but betting on one player against the field is risky. While 2025 looks favorable, history suggests caution. - John Schwarb: FACT
Quail Hollow feels like the perfect stage for Rory to shine. Oakmont’s challenging layout also suits his game, giving him a strong chance.
Is LIV Golf’s Scheduling Strategy a Mistake?
LIV Golf continues to schedule events alongside key PGA Tour stops, including the FedEx Cup playoffs. Is this approach counterproductive?
- Bob Harig: FACT
LIV’s original promise of being “additive” to golf fades when it competes directly with PGA Tour events. The viewership gap remains massive, making this strategy questionable. - Jeff Ritter: FICTION
LIV can’t avoid all conflicts with the PGA Tour. Competing during playoffs makes sense for LIV players who can’t participate in those events, but steering clear of major Tour dates would help. - John Schwarb: NEUTRAL
LIV faces scheduling challenges, often dictated by venue availability. However, competing directly with marquee PGA Tour events isn’t ideal for growth.
Will Nelly Korda Reach 40 Career Wins and Crack the LPGA’s Top 10?
After securing her 15th career win at the Annika, can Nelly Korda sustain her dominance to achieve 40 wins?
- Bob Harig: FICTION
A remarkable goal but unlikely given today’s short career peaks. Sustaining a five-win annual pace over the next decade is a tall order. - Jeff Ritter: FICTION
While Korda’s current form is stellar, maintaining this level for long enough to triple her win count feels improbable. - John Schwarb: FACT
Korda’s dominance in regular events positions her for greatness. If she builds on this momentum, 40 wins and a top-10 spot could be within reach.
Your Turn: Do you agree with our takes? Share your thoughts on the SI Golf X account and join the conversation!
Source: SI
